Disclosure: Ink makes one of the journals on this list. We've kept every claim about the others to what their own websites say, with links, checked on Nov 19, 2026. Prices and features change, so check each site before you buy.
Most trading journals were built for people trading their own money. A prop firm trader has a different problem: every account lives or dies by a set of rules (max loss, daily loss, consistency, a profit target) and every failed evaluation costs a fee. So the questions that matter are different:
- Does it know your firm's rules, or do you type them in?
- Does it warn you before you break one?
- Can it tell you if your trading would pass a plan before you pay for it?
- Does it show what your evals have cost against what you've been paid?
Here's how five popular journals answer those questions.
Quick comparison
| Ink | TradeZella | TraderSync | Edgewonk | Tradervue | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price (monthly) | $29 ink+ ¹ | $29 Basic · $49 Pro | $29.95 · $49.95 · $79.95 | $35 | $29.95 · $49.95 |
| Prop firm rules built in | Yes, rules for 21 firms | Yes (PropFirm Sync), auto-filled for supported firms | Not listed on its pricing page | Not described; tracks prop accounts | Not mentioned on its pricing page |
| "Would you pass this plan?" before buying | Yes, replays your last 30 days against each plan (estimate) | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Not mentioned |
| Simulated odds of passing | Yes (estimate) | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Not mentioned |
| Eval costs vs payouts | Yes, fee tracker | Fee fields per challenge | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Not mentioned |
| Broker auto-sync | No (CSV or MT5 report import) | Yes, 100+ brokers | Yes | Trade imports | Yes |
| Trade replay | No | Pro plan | Yes | No | No |
1. Ink: best for prop firm traders
Price: ink+ $29/month from Dec 1, 2026 (until then $19/month or $190/year). See pricing.
Ink is built around prop firm rules first. Pick your firm and plan when you add an account, and the rules come with it: max loss and how it trails, daily loss, consistency, profit target. Every trade and every day is checked against them.
What's different:
- Would you pass? Ink replays your last 30 days against every plan it knows, so you can see which plans your trading fits before you buy one. It's an estimate, not a guarantee.
- Odds of passing: for an evaluation account, Ink replays your own trades 1,000 times at the risk you choose and shows your chance of hitting the target before the max loss.
- What it's cost you: the fee tracker puts every eval fee, reset and activation next to your payouts, so you see your real net from prop trading.
- Free rule pages and calculators: rules and prices for 21 firms, plus a trailing drawdown calculator and a consistency calculator, all free without an account.




Watch out for:
- No broker auto-sync yet. You import a CSV (Tradovate, TopstepX, or a mapped CSV from NinjaTrader, Rithmic and more) or an MT5 report, or log trades by hand.
- No trade replay or backtesting.
- Newer than the others, with a smaller community.
2. TradeZella: best all-rounder
Price: Basic $29/month (1 account), Pro $49/month (up to 20 accounts); $288 or $399 per year. (pricing)
TradeZella is the most complete general journal here: auto-sync with 100+ brokers, 50+ reports, a notebook, and trade replay and backtesting on Pro. Its PropFirm Sync lets you add a challenge and track its profit target, daily loss, max drawdown (static, EOD or trailing) and best-day consistency, with rules filled in automatically for supported firms. (help article)
Watch out for: Basic allows one trading account, so anyone running several evals needs Pro. We couldn't find a "would you pass this plan" check or pass-odds simulation in its documentation.
3. TraderSync: best for replay and AI
Price: Pro $29.95, Premium $49.95, Elite $79.95 per month. (pricing summary)
Strong replay (down to 250 ms on Elite), broker auto-import and an AI assistant. Premium adds an Evaluator that models how your behaviour affects P&L.
Watch out for: prop firm rule tracking isn't listed on its pricing page. Pro caps the AI and limits broker accounts.
4. Edgewonk: best for psychology and edge analysis
Price: $35/month or $197/year. (pricing)
One plan with everything: unlimited journals and accounts, a Tiltmeter for how often you break your own rules, an Edge Finder, MAE/MFE and a performance simulator. It says you can "track unlimited prop firm accounts".
Watch out for: its pricing page doesn't describe tracking prop firm rules like daily loss or max drawdown, so you'd manage those yourself.
5. Tradervue: best for simple broker sync
Price: Silver $29.95/month, Gold $49.95/month. (pricing)
A long-running journal with unlimited imports and accounts, broker sync, mentor sharing and solid reports. Gold adds exit analysis and commissions/fees support.
Watch out for: its pricing page doesn't mention prop firm rule tracking.
Which one should you pick?
- You trade prop firm evaluations and want to know which plans you'd pass: Ink.
- You want the most complete journal and need broker auto-sync today: TradeZella.
- You care most about replay and AI review: TraderSync.
- You want one simple price and psychology tools: Edgewonk.
Not sure your trading fits a plan? Check it free with the rule pages, or see if your own trades would pass.
Prices and features checked on Nov 19, 2026 from each company's site. Firm and product names belong to their owners. Ink isn't affiliated with them.


